Reading Response · #1A
First-Contact Picture Books (Encounter / Pedro's Journal)
Compare two perspectives on October 12, 1492 — the Taíno point of view in Encounter and the Spanish ship's-boy view in Pedro's Journal.
After reading Encounter (Jane Yolen) and an excerpt of Pedro's Journal (Pam Conrad), answer in full sentences. Cite specific details from each book.
- Encounter is told from the perspective of a Taíno boy. How does that change the way you understand the events of 1492? Use a specific moment.
- Pedro's Journal is told from the perspective of a Spanish ship's boy. What does Pedro notice and worry about? Cite one specific detail.
- Both books describe the same historical moment. Choose one event (the arrival of the ships, the meeting on the shore, the gift-giving) and explain how the two accounts differ. Use a quote from each.
- What theme do you see in Encounter? Write one sentence and explain how you decided.
- Imagine a third perspective — an animal, an elder, or a sailor. Write 3–4 sentences from that perspective describing one moment from October 12, 1492.
Scoring: 4-Point Writing Rubric (focus on Evidence and Ideas).